All the latest news from the industry weekly compiled by the editorial team for you free of charge.
This eMail is already registered.
An unexpected error occured.
Please accept our Terms of Use.
Registration successful.

Professor Jörg Krüger

Head of the Industrial Automation Technology Department - Institute of Machine Tools and Factory Management (IWF) at the Technical
University of Berlin

Director of the Automation Technology Division - Fraunhofer IPK

2 Ratings

WIRELESS AUTOMATION Doomed to fail without AI?

May 3, 2019

Professor Jörg Krüger, Head of the Industrial Automation Technology Department, Institute of Machine Tools and Factory Management (IWF) at the Technical University of Berlin, and Director of the Automation Technology Division at Fraunhofer IPK, is making the necessary wake-up call for Artificial Intelligence (AI). He gives his pessimistic view of AI and new value creation models. Excerpts…

How and when did you first come into contact with AI?

That was in 1992 when I was exploring the use of artificial neural networks in the diagnosis of machine tool axes. Today, I am fascinated by the tremendous advances made in deep learning (part of machine learning based on neural networks and large amounts of data) and convolutional neural networks (according to Wikipedia, a machine learning concept inspired by biological processes), some of which already exceed human capabilities in pattern and image recognition in the
processing of audio and video data.

What do you think of the pessimistic views on AI?

Some aspects are becoming ever more complex and so I understand the scepticism regarding the inscrutability of these systems. We need to create simpler automation structures that facilitate better understanding of and control over the complexity of machine learning. The issue is whether production engineers can trust a self-learning system enough for them to deploy it in production. Education and training often don’t adapt quickly enough to such rapid developments in re-search. This means that only with a considerable delay are we able to acquire the skills necessary to master this complexity and build confidence in these new technologies. All this, of course, fuels the notion that humans will eventually be pushed aside.

And then the production engineers find themselves confronted with a mountain of Big Data - what should they do with this?

It depends very much on what kind of data you are talking about and what the production engineer’s objective is. One user, for example, wanted to use image recognition to identify and manage 50,000 to 60,000 parts in a warehouse. Previously, a warehouse worker would do the work of identifying and sorting the parts using a catalogue. We only had a limited number of images taken of each part, not enough to map a neural network structure. However, we found that by using pre-trained networks based on non-industrial image data in combination with a limited amount of industrial component data, it was possible to achieve acceptable recognition rates for providing assistance functions even from an early stage. The AI system then works as a semiautomatic assistant that displays the five most likely parts to the warehouse worker. Thanks to this assistance, he now works much more efficiently and accurately. But this only works if you know the processes very well.

That’s why my message is: don’t just invest in hardware and software, you also need to make systematic use of the “domain knowledge” of the production staff. People must also learn to evaluate processes in the factory and decide which tasks AI can take over. The inclusion of domain knowledge from production is crucial in order to identify new areas of value creation potential quickly and systematically.

The data generated by companies is digital gold dust for me. In my experience, many companies are not yet aware of just what value creation potential it holds. Machine learning tools are becoming increasingly powerful. In production, we should now be systematically combining data with domain knowledge in order to refine processes and make them more efficient. I’m interested in tackling this issue with colleagues from WGP (Wissenschaftliche Gesellschaft für Produktionstechnik - German Academic Society for Production Engineering). For example, we should no longer be focusing on increasing recognition rates with the help of machine learning methods as we did in the past. Instead, we should be analysing the potential of existing production data for machine learning more systematically than before and exploiting the resulting potential for raising production efficiency levels more systematically.

I recommend watching the YouTube video by the Canadian scientist, Ajay Agrawal or reading his book Prediction Machines: The Simple Economics of Artificial Intelligence. Here, automation or production engineers view the opportunities of AI from an economic perspective in order to discover the digital gold dust in their own company. Completely new value creation models and niches suddenly emerge for small businesses, especially for start-ups.

What role will sensors play?

“Sensorisation” is usually the first step in acquiring data for learning. The more powerful and cost-effective the tools for machine learning are, the more valuable the underlying data becomes. Especially in the field of sensorisation, great progress is being made in research and development in relation to Industry 4.0, a good prerequisite for taking the next step towards machine learning in production.

What are you most interested in seeing at EMO Hannover 2019, not only in your capacity as a production engineering researcher interested in AI?

I’ll certainly be interested in seeing the exhibits being presented by our WGP colleagues. For example, I heard that an institute will be showcasing something very exciting in the field of pattern recognition on machine tool drives. It should also be worthwhile checking out the stands of some machine manufacturers and automation companies.


Image Gallery

  • Professor Jörg Krüger is Director of the Department for Industrial Automation Technology of the Institute of Machine Tools and Factory Management (IWF) at TU Berlin and Director of the Division for Automation Technology of the Fraunhofer Institute for Production Systems and Design Technology (IPK). His research is focused on automation systems for flexible production. Together with his team, he develops innovative systems for human robot collaboration in assembly as well as new methods for machine vision, data mining & cloud-based control in production.

Related articles